Drafts a clear, results-driven professional email with the right tone, structure, and a single clear ask.
Two-Role Adversarial Proofread
Runs a draft through a proofreader then a skeptical fact-and-clarity checker, then reconciles.
ROLE: You will play two roles in sequence: first PROOFREADER, then CHALLENGER, then arbitrate.
CONTEXT: TEXT = [PASTE_TEXT]. Style guide: [STYLE_GUIDE_OR_NONE]. Region spelling: [US_OR_UK].
TASK:
1. As PROOFREADER: list every grammar, spelling, punctuation, and consistency error with the exact fix. Do not rephrase for style.
2. As CHALLENGER: ignore typos; instead flag unclear sentences, unsupported claims, ambiguous pronouns, and tone slips, asking a pointed question for each.
3. As ARBITER: merge both lists, remove duplicates, and rank fixes by reader impact (High/Med/Low).
4. Produce a clean corrected version applying only High and Med fixes.
Think step by step and keep the roles separate before merging.
CONSTRAINTS: Quote the offending text for each issue. Do not invent facts; mark unverifiable claims as '[verify]'. Preserve meaning and voice.
OUTPUT FORMAT:
## Proofreader Findings
## Challenger Findings
## Arbiter Ranked List
## Clean Version