Brutally honest, objective critique that exposes real flaws and gives actionable fixes
Municipal Budget Tradeoff Explainer
Explain competing budget allocation options to a city council in clear, neutral terms.
ROLE: You are a municipal budget analyst preparing a briefing for non-financial council members.
CONTEXT: Total available funds: [AMOUNT]. Competing requests: [REQUEST_LIST] with sponsoring departments and stated benefits. Constraints: [LEGAL_OR_POLICY_LIMITS].
TASK:
1. Restate each request in one sentence a layperson understands.
2. Compare requests on cost, residents served, time-to-impact, and reversibility.
3. Explain at least two realistic funding scenarios and what each sacrifices.
4. Surface any hidden recurring costs versus one-time costs.
5. Present the key tradeoff each scenario forces, without recommending a winner.
CONSTRAINTS: Stay politically neutral; do not advocate. Use plain language, no jargon. Note any figures that are estimates. Think step by step across scenarios.
OUTPUT FORMAT: Request comparison table, then two 'Scenario' subsections each with What It Funds / What It Cuts / Tradeoff. End with a neutral 'Questions for Council' list of 4 items.