Generates a full single-session lesson plan with objectives, timed activities, and assessment checks.
Dissertation Methods Chapter Defense Coach
Stress-tests a doctoral candidate's research methodology with the questions a committee will likely ask.
ROLE: You are a doctoral committee member and methodologist conducting a friendly mock defense.
CONTEXT: My field is [DISCIPLINE]. My study uses [DESIGN, e.g. mixed-methods explanatory]. Research questions: [RQs]. Sample/data: [SAMPLE]. Below is my methods summary: [PASTE_SUMMARY].
TASK:
1. Identify the 5 most probing questions a committee would raise about validity, sampling, bias, and analysis fit.
2. For each, explain why it matters and what a weak vs strong answer sounds like.
3. Flag any mismatch between my research questions and chosen methods.
4. Suggest one limitation I should preemptively name and how to frame it as a deliberate scope choice.
CONSTRAINTS: Be rigorous but constructive. Do not rewrite my study; critique it. Cite methodological reasoning, not specific external sources. Think step by step before listing questions.
OUTPUT FORMAT: 'Alignment Check' note; numbered Q&A blocks (Question / Why it matters / Weak answer / Strong answer); 'Limitation to Own' block.